From Classic to Contemporary: Choosing the Best Bourbon for Your Old Fashioned

Bourbon lovers, rejoice! So grab your glass and get ready to elevate your cocktail game!

Introduction to the Old Fashioned cocktail and its history

But where did this iconic drink originate, and how has it evolved over the years?

At that time, a local bartender by the name of James E. Pepper created a new style of drink using bourbon whiskey, sugar, water, bitters and garnish. This was a refreshing change from the popular spirit-heavy cocktails of that era. The drink quickly gained popularity among locals and soon became a favorite across the country.

As with many cocktails, there are several stories surrounding the creation of the Old Fashioned. Pepper’s grandson who introduced this particular recipe at New York City’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel.

Scott Fitzgerald’s “The Great Gatsby” and Clint Eastwood’s “Dirty Harry.”

Today, the Old Fashioned has made a comeback as a go-to drink for those who appreciate a well-made classic cocktail.

Basics of bourbon: what it is and how it differs from other whiskies

However, many people are still unsure about what exactly makes bourbon different from other types of whiskies. In this section, we will delve into the basics of bourbon and explore its distinct characteristics.

This aging process gives bourbon its signature color and imparts unique flavors to the spirit.

One key factor that sets bourbon apart from other types of whiskey is its mash bill. As mentioned before, it must contain at least 51% corn; however, the remaining ingredients can vary greatly. Some bourbons use rye as their second most abundant grain, while others may use wheat or barley instead. This variation in grains leads to differences in flavor profiles among different brands of bourbon.

Another distinguishing feature of bourbon is its aging process in new charred oak barrels. These barrels give off complex flavors such as caramelized sugars and spice notes due to the charring process.

However, each brand will have its unique blend of flavors depending on their mash bill and aging techniques.

While all bourbon is whiskey, not all whiskey can be classified as bourbon.

Bourbon stands out from other whiskies due to its specific production requirements and unique flavor profile.

Understanding the flavor profile of bourbon and how it affects an Old Fashioned

The length of time spent aging in barrels also contributes to bourbon’s flavor profile. Older bourbons tend to have richer and more complex flavors due to longer exposure to wood and air oxidation. On the other hand, younger bourbons may have bolder notes from their high alcohol content but lack depth.

All of these elements work together to create a unique flavor profile for each bourbon.

So how does the flavor profile of bourbon affect an Old Fashioned? On the other hand, those with more rye or barley may provide a spicier kick to the cocktail.

Experimenting with different types of bourbon can help you find your ideal match for an unforgettable Old Fashioned experience.

Types of bourbon for an Old Fashioned: traditional vs. modern options

When it comes to making the perfect Old Fashioned, one of the key ingredients is the bourbon. However, bourbon has become a popular alternative due to its sweeter and smoother taste profile.

Traditional bourbons are those that follow the time-honored method of production and have been around for decades. They also tend to have a higher proof, which adds depth and complexity to the drink.

On the other hand, modern bourbons differ from their traditional counterparts in terms of production methods and flavor profiles. These bourbons often use different grains such as wheat or barley instead of rye, resulting in a sweeter taste.

Ultimately, whether you choose a traditional or modern bourbon for your Old Fashioned comes down to personal preference. Traditional options provide a familiar and reliable taste, while modern options offer something new and exciting.

How to choose the best bourbon for your personal taste and budget

However, with so many options available, choosing the best bourbon for your personal taste and budget can be overwhelming. In this section, we will discuss some key factors to consider when selecting the perfect bourbon for your old fashioned.

  1. Know Your Budget:
    The first step in choosing the best bourbon is to determine your budget.
  2. Consider Your Personal Taste Preferences:
    It’s crucial to consider what flavors you typically enjoy in other spirits or foods when selecting a bourbon.
  3. Understand the Mash Bill:
    Mash bill refers to the combination of grains used in making bourbon.
  4. Age Matters:
    Just like wine or scotch, aging plays an essential role in the flavor profile of bourbon. However, this also means a higher price tag as older bourbons tend to be more expensive.
  5. Research Brands and Read Reviews:
    With numerous brands on the market, it can be challenging to know which bourbon will suit your taste buds. Take the time to research different brands and read reviews from experts and fellow enthusiasts. This will give you a better understanding of the flavor profiles and overall quality of various bourbons.
  6. Don’t Be Afraid to Experiment:
    When it comes down to it, the best way to find the perfect bourbon for your old fashioned is through trial and error. Don’t be afraid to try new brands and styles until you find the one that satisfies your personal taste preferences.

Choosing the best bourbon for your old fashioned requires careful consideration of budget, personal taste preferences, mash bill, age, brand reputation, and experimentation. With these factors in mind, you’ll be sure to find a delicious bourbon that perfectly complements your cocktail.

Tips for making the perfect Old Fashioned with your chosen bourbon

Making the perfect Old Fashioned with your chosen bourbon can seem like a daunting task, but fear not! With the right tips and techniques, you can create a delicious and well-balanced cocktail that will have you savoring every sip. Here are some tips for mastering this classic drink:

  1. Start with Quality Ingredients: The key to any great cocktail is using high-quality ingredients. When it comes to an Old Fashioned, the main ingredient is, of course, the bourbon. Choose a premium bourbon that has complex flavors and notes such as caramel, vanilla, oak, or spice. This will give your Old Fashioned depth and character.
  2. Use Fresh Citrus: Using fresh citrus in your Old Fashioned is essential for achieving a bright and refreshing flavor profile. Squeeze fresh orange peel over the drink to release its oils before adding it as a garnish. You can also add a dash of fresh lemon juice for an extra zesty kick.
  3. Don’t Overdo It on the Sugar: Traditionally, an Old Fashioned calls for a sugar cube or simple syrup as a sweetener. However, be careful not to add too much sweetness as it can overpower the flavors of the bourbon. Start with half a teaspoon of sugar or less and adjust according to your taste.
  4. Use a high-quality aromatic bitters such as Angostura or orange bitters for best results.

Remember, practice makes perfect! Don’t be afraid to experiment and make adjustments to find your perfect ratio of ingredients. With these tips in hand, you’ll be well on your way to making the perfect Old Fashioned every time using your chosen bourbon. Cheers!

Other factors to consider when choosing a bourbon,


One factor to consider is the age of the bourbon. In general, older bourbons tend to be smoother and more complex in flavor. Some younger bourbons may also have unique flavors and characteristics that can enhance your drink. It ultimately depends on personal preference and experimentation.

Type of Mash Bill

A mash bill refers to the specific combination of grains used in making the whiskey, which can greatly affect its flavor profile. Traditional bourbon mash bills consist primarily of corn (at least 51%), followed by rye or wheat as secondary grains, with a small amount of malted barley added for enzymes to aid fermentation.

However, contemporary bourbons often use alternative grains such as barley or oats, resulting in a different taste profile compared to traditional bourbons. Experimenting with different types of mash bills can add complexity and depth to your Old Fashioned cocktail.

Single Barrel vs Small Batch

You may also come across terms like “single barrel” or “small batch” when browsing through different bourbon options. Single barrel bourbons tend to be more consistent in flavor, while small batch bourbons can have slight variations between batches. Again, this is a matter of personal preference and experimentation.

When choosing the best bourbon for your Old Fashioned, do not limit yourself to just flavor and proof. Consider these other factors as well to find the perfect match for your taste preferences. Remember, the beauty of making cocktails at home is that you have the freedom to experiment and create your own unique blend for a truly personalized experience.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *